Mobilehelp vs Medical Guardian: Which is Better for Seniors? [2026 Comparison]

When you’re shopping for a medical alert system for a parent, MobileHelp and Medical Guardian keep coming up together because they genuinely are the two most-recommended services in the same price bracket. Both offer 24/7 monitoring, fall detection, and a mix of home and on-the-go devices, which makes choosing between them genuinely confusing if you don’t know what to look for.

We’ll give you a clear answer by the end of this article. That said, the right pick really does depend on your parent’s lifestyle and living situation, so it’s worth reading a bit past the summary box before you decide.

Quick Comparison: MobileHelp vs Medical Guardian

MobileHelp: Overview

MobileHelp has been in the medical alert space since 2006 and has built a strong reputation specifically for seniors who don’t stay home all day. The company’s strength is its cellular-based GPS system, which means your parent isn’t tethered to a landline or a home base unit to get protection. Their classic bundle includes both a home base and a mobile GPS device, so you’re covered indoors and out without paying for two separate subscriptions.

The pricing is where MobileHelp really stands out in this comparison. Their entry-level home plan starts around $19.95 per month, which is noticeably cheaper than most competitors. For a fixed-income parent, that difference adds up over a year. The tradeoff is that the devices aren’t the prettiest things you’ve ever seen. They’re functional and clearly medical, which some seniors find reassuring and others find stigmatising.

When we helped set up a MobileHelp Classic for a parent with mild arthritis, the large help button was genuinely easy to press even with stiff fingers. The base unit also speaks back to confirm it heard the alert, which meant less anxiety about whether the button had worked. That kind of reassurance matters more than most product listings acknowledge.

Pros:

• Lower monthly cost than most competitors, especially for the home plan
• Flexible bundles that combine home and mobile coverage in one subscription
• Large, easy-to-press button that works well for seniors with dexterity issues
• No long-term contracts, and the cancellation process is reportedly painless

Cons:

• The mobile device needs daily charging, which some seniors find hard to remember
• Device design looks noticeably medical and some seniors resist wearing it
• Customer service wait times have been reported as longer than ideal during peak hours

See MobileHelp’s current plans and pricing

Medical Guardian: Overview

Medical Guardian was founded in 2005 and has positioned itself as the more premium option in this category. Their device lineup is broader than MobileHelp’s, ranging from a basic home unit to the MGMove, which is a wristwatch-style device that genuinely doesn’t look like a medical alert product. For seniors who feel self-conscious about wearing an obvious help button, that matters a lot.

The monitoring centre is one of Medical Guardian’s genuine strengths. They’re U.S.-based, TMA Five Diamond certified, and have consistently received solid marks in independent monitoring response-time tests. Their mobile app for caregivers is well-designed and gives you real-time location tracking without being invasive or difficult to interpret at a glance.

The pricing is higher across the board compared to MobileHelp, and some of the more capable devices carry an upfront equipment cost on top of the monthly fee. If your parent wants the MGMove watch, you’re looking at a higher investment overall. Whether that’s worth it depends entirely on how much the design factor matters to getting your parent to actually wear the device every day.

Pros:

• Sleeker, more modern device options including a smartwatch-style unit
• Choice of AT&T or Verizon networks, which helps in areas with patchy AT&T coverage
• Excellent monitoring centre reputation with fast response times
• Strong caregiver app with clear location tracking

Cons:

• Higher monthly cost than MobileHelp, especially once fall detection is added
• Some devices carry an upfront equipment fee that MobileHelp typically waives
• The MGMove watch’s battery life is better than rivals, but it still needs regular charging

See Medical Guardian’s current plans and pricing

Head-to-Head: The Details That Matter for Seniors

Ease of Use

MobileHelp wins this one for seniors with physical limitations. The button on the classic pendant is larger and requires less precise pressing than Medical Guardian’s equivalent. For a parent with Parkinson’s tremors or significant arthritis, that’s not a minor detail. Medical Guardian’s devices are generally well-designed, but the sleeker form factor sometimes means smaller buttons, and the MGMove watch interface has a small learning curve that some seniors find frustrating in the first week.

That said, if your parent is relatively tech-comfortable and prioritises wearing something that doesn’t announce “I’m a medical alert device,” Medical Guardian’s watch is genuinely easy to use once the initial setup is done.

Setup: Can a Family Member Do It Remotely?

This is honestly one of the most important questions for our audience, because many of you are setting this up for a parent who lives in a different city. Both companies ship the device pre-paired to their monitoring network, which means your parent doesn’t need to enter account details or pair anything to Wi-Fi. That’s a big deal.

MobileHelp’s home base plugs into a power outlet and a phone line or cellular signal, and the setup guide is clear enough that most parents can follow it with a phone call from you. Medical Guardian’s setup is similarly plug-and-go for the home unit. Where Medical Guardian pulls ahead slightly is in its caregiver app, which lets you verify that the device is online and working from your phone without having to call your parent and ask them to check the light on the base unit.

Cost Over Time

Let’s look at a real two-year scenario. With MobileHelp’s Classic plan at roughly $19.95 per month plus fall detection at $10 per month, you’re looking at around $719 over two years with no equipment fee. With Medical Guardian’s home plan at approximately $29.95 per month plus fall detection, the same two years costs around $959, potentially more if you paid an equipment fee upfront.

That’s a meaningful difference of roughly $240 over two years, and more if you opt for Medical Guardian’s premium devices. For families paying out of pocket (most medical alert systems aren’t covered by Medicare), MobileHelp is the clearer choice on pure cost grounds.

Reliability and Support

Both companies use U.S.-based monitoring centres and both have been in business long enough to have weathered real emergencies at scale. We’d call reliability roughly equal at the device level. Where they differ is in support experience. Medical Guardian’s customer service reviews are generally more positive in recent years, with shorter hold times and better follow-through on technical issues. MobileHelp has improved but still gets occasional complaints about difficult cancellation calls, which is worth knowing upfront.

For fall detection accuracy specifically, neither company is perfect. Both use accelerometer-based detection that can trigger falsely during vigorous movement, which is a limitation of the technology across the entire industry rather than a specific failing of either brand.

Which Should You Choose?

Choose MobileHelp if Your Parent…

• Is on a fixed income and needs the lowest reliable monthly cost available
• Has arthritis, tremors, or reduced grip strength and needs a large, easy-to-press button
• Splits time between home and the garden, a senior centre, or regular walks and needs both environments covered affordably
• Doesn’t mind wearing a device that looks like a medical alert and just wants something that works

Choose Medical Guardian if Your Parent…

• Has pushed back on wearing a medical alert because “it looks like an old person’s thing” and the MGMove watch might actually get worn
• Lives in an area with weak AT&T signal and would benefit from the Verizon network option
• Spends most of their time at home but you want the cleaner caregiver app experience for your own peace of mind
• Values a more polished customer service experience and is willing to pay a bit more for it

Consider a Third Option If…

If your parent is still relatively independent but you want passive fall detection without them having to press anything, Bay Alarm Medical and Life Alert both offer features worth comparing. And if your parent already uses an Apple Watch, the built-in fall detection on the Apple Watch Series 9 or Ultra is genuinely capable and removes the “I hate wearing that thing” argument entirely, though it does require a paired iPhone to function properly.

Check MobileHelp on Amazon →

Check Medical Guardian on Amazon →

Frequently Asked Questions

Does MobileHelp or Medical Guardian Work Better in Rural Areas?

Medical Guardian has a slight edge here because they offer both AT&T and Verizon network options.